American founder St. George Tucker prepared an American
edition of Blackstone, updating it with commentaries and footnotes applicable
to American government.
He wrote:
"It is easy to perceive that a government
originally founded upon consent, and compact, may by gradual usurpations on the
part of the public functionaries, change its type, altogether, and become a
government of force. In this case, the people are as completely enslaved as if
the original foundations of the government had been laid by conquest.
"Thus, the nature of a government, so far as respects the
freedom of the people, may be considered as depending upon the nature of the
bond of their union. If the bond of the union be the voluntary consent of the
people, the government may be pronounced to be free; where constraint and fear
constitute the bond, the government is no longer the government of the people,
and consequently they are enslaved."
What bond do most citizens today have with their
government--one of voluntary consent or one of constraint and fear?
Certainly we
have more voluntary consent and less constraint and fear than many people around the world, but how do we compare to, say, most citizens in the 1950s or
1980s or even the 1920s?
|